I loved the book I started the book and I had to finish it that day!

Best book ever!!!!!!

This book is really good and it takes a sudden twist. She was in the attic and she discovered something. How did she know it would make her Grandfather mad. She had never seen him so mad. How could she figure out how to talk to him and figure out why he was so angry about her discovery?

this is a really good book!!! I really liked It. I definitely recommend it!! I liked all of the characters- Especially Zayde, and Ben. oh and of course Shirli I like how Zayde unfolds his life in bits. This book has a lot of surprises and twists and turns!!!

This book is amazing you should definitely read it!!